The Best LFC Manager in 25 years?

[redhorizon2]

Who in your opinion gets that award? Who gets the wooden spoon?

 

[gkmacca]

Rafa.


Hodge.

 

[leftpeg]

Given that Kenny left in 91, presumably we can include him in the list and take account of what he did right from the beginning of his tenure...therefore I'm going with:

1. Dalglish
2. Benitez
3. Houllier
4. Evans
5. Souness
6. Rodgers
7. Moran
8. Hodgson

 

[Judge Jules]

Mostly agree, but last season puts Rodgers ahead of Uncle Roy and Souey for me.

 

[leftpeg]

Mostly agree, but last season puts Rodgers ahead of Uncle Roy and Souey for me.

It's a close run thing but Souness and Evans both won trophies so they edge Rodgers...for now at least!

 

[Tinto]

Mostly agree, but last season puts Rodgers ahead of Uncle Roy and Souey for me.

I think you would need to if you believe we should stick with Rodgers...

 

[leftpeg]

In 96/97 under Roy we had a run at the league not unlike last season...five point lead at one stage before fading to 3rd...so that surely matches Rodgers' effort in 13/14.

 

[Judge Jules]

Fair points, Lefty.

Tinto: I'd replace Rodgers if Ancelotti were up for the job, because it's Ancelotti and because I've always had doubts about the idea of appointing a young manager to the LFC job anyway. If Klopp's the alternative I'm not convinced the time is right, after the season he's just had. If in a year's time he's recharged his batteries and hasn't taken another job, and if Rodgers doesn't get a minimum of a CL place next season, that'll be a different story.

 

[Insignificance]

Given that Kenny left in 91, presumably we can include him in the list and take account of what he did right from the beginning of his tenure...therefore I'm going with:

1. Dalglish
2. Benitez
3. Houllier
4. Evans
5. Souness
6. Rodgers
7. Moran
8. Hodgson

Agree

 

[Hansern]

Rodgers is well ahead of Souness for me. Souness was a terrible manager.
Winning the FA cup doesnt change the fact that he only won 40% of his games in charge.
Shocking transfer dealings aswell.

 

[hamstrung_pigeon]

Given that Kenny left in 91, presumably we can include him in the list and take account of what he did right from the beginning of his tenure...therefore I'm going with:

1. Dalglish
2. Benitez
3. Houllier
4. Evans
5. Souness
6. Rodgers
7. Moran
8. Hodgson

You probably have to include Phil Thompson as well I suppose?

 

[leftpeg]

You probably have to include Phil Thompson as well I suppose?

Indeed...if we're including Moran. Ok, Thommo slots in at number 2!

 

[nealmac]

Kenny (first term)
Rafa
Houlier

 

[Gerry_A_Trick]

If it's 24 years, as I assume was meant, it'd be something like this:
1. Benitez
2. Houllier
3. Evans
4. Souness
5. Rodgers
6. Dalglish
7. Moran
8. Hodgson