• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Sporting director

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's a ridiculous shot any pro should be embarrassed of taking. An iPhone could do better. And yes, a ton of issues from composition to perspective to distortion. Simply no excuse for a pro as no matter what lens he has on he should still be aware enough of it's strengths and weaknesses.

Nah. Every photographer churns out a steaming turd of a shot every now and then regardless of how well they know their equipment or what level they are working at.

The shot doesn't work - thanks to the issues you pointed out - but Powell shouldn't feel embarrassed for taking it, he should have thought twice before including it in his public portfolio though because it doesn't sit well with some other very well executed photos.
 
JS99091036.jpg


Every time I see this photo it drives me absolutely nuts ! Such an amateurish photo. Every pro should know that wide angle lenses distort horribly the closer you get to the margins and compensate for that. Preferably in this case by taking a few steps back and using a 50mm or 85mm lens and not the likely 16-35mm lens that was used. Infuriating !

Glad to get that off my chest. *goes back to surfing*
I've said it before in relation to this photo ... there is Linda and then just blur all around
 
A smarter way to use statistics would be to pay twitter for direct access to their servers. Then analyse the tweets of football fans in relation to every player. It would be better than sending a single scout, you'd have billions of scouts, all around the world. You could even engaging in a bit of spoofing, and send billions of fake positive tweets about Lucas, forcing someone to take notice and buy him.
Release the Arn!
 
He can't be any worse at signing players than Ian Ayre. Every time i read that he was jetting off somewhere to conclude a deal for a player I always expected it to fall through and it usually did, especially in Ukraine.
He seems to have been going through a mid life crisis for the last few years. Just off the top of my head i can recall the hooters girls in ukraine, the robbie fowler picture, his motorbike , the ticket prices gaffe , the whole 'being Liverpool' thing , the Joe allen shirt number suggestion etc
If we've got faith in Klopp then doesn't that mean we have to trust who he's got faith in?
 
Oh its definitely his money, but when she closes her eyes, its my lad she is imagining
 
Am I the only one a little concerned that a 37 year old will be negotiating transfers?

I know he's not exactly a baby, but top level contract negotiations are a chess game, & the skills are honed over time & experience is massive.

There's always a chance this fella has been shadowing people negotiating for many years, & as such has a lot of experience, but if they're just putting him in the role cos he's good with numbers & analytics this could be a mistake.

He might not be directly negotiating transfers - someone else at the club might be responsible for that.
 
http://www.joe.co.uk/sport/liverpool/95890

Tony Barrett:
[article]In the recent past it seemed that every major decision at Liverpool caused an earthquake.

The absence of stability meant change was often rapid, sometimes sudden and occasionally unnecessary. Today when they announced that Michael Edwards had ascended to the position of sporting director, a new role at the club and one of great significance, there was no shock value. This is a change that seems totally natural and it caused not even a tremor.

There has been much to commend Liverpool for since Jurgen Klopp was appointed manager a year ago. Most notably, the quality of the football they have played and the results they have earned have improved steadily to the point that they are now widely considered to be title contenders.

But what has gone largely overlooked is just how stable they have become as a club. The elevation of Edwards, one which has the blessing of Klopp, is wholly in keeping with the consistency of approach and sense of collective endeavour which underpins their revival.

Promotion from within, once someone had proved themselves able, was always the Liverpool way. When the club was at its most effective in the 1960s, 70s and 80s, individuals would rise through the ranks to take senior positions if they were good enough rather than looking to outsiders to come in and make changes. Edwards has a great deal to do if he is to live up to the standards of those who emerged that way in the past but his appointment is, at the very least, wholly in keeping with that tradition.

Brought to Liverpool by Damien Comolli, the then director of football, five years ago this month, Edwards's influence at the club has grown significantly having arrived initially as head of performance and analysis. In June 2013, he was promoted to the position of director of technical performance, a role he performed for two years before being made technical director in August 2015.

It has to be said that his influence has not always been as appreciated outside of Anfield as it has been inside.

Criticism of his methods has been widespread, at times justifiably but at others it has been personal and unfair, but his employers, particularly Mike Gordon, the president of Fenway Sports Group (FSG), continued to hold him in high regard despite the doubts that surrounded him.

A key factor in Edwards's latest promotion is that Gordon credits him with having played a leading role in the progress that Liverpool have made under Klopp having laid some of the groundwork before his arrival.

Having done everything in their power to distance themselves from the transfer committee tag which caused them no end of problems, Liverpool are not about to start assigning past signings to different individuals but it is an open secret that moves for the likes of Roberto Firmino, Divock Origi, Emre Can and Sadio Mane were all driven, to a lesser or greater extent, by Edwards.

As recently as twelve months ago, the quality of the first three in that quartet was open to question but now, under Klopp's management, the complexion is very different.

"John [W Henry], Tom [Werner] and I are delighted Michael has accepted this new role. He is an extremely talented football executive who has demonstrated his exceptional value to the club. Both Jürgen and I know LFC will be stronger as a result of his appointment," Gordon said today.

“When Jürgen was named manager, he was clear that the high quality of our playing squad was an important factor in his decision process; Michael has been integral to assembling the squad and we are confident he is ready to make this next step in his career.”

The strength of the rapport that Edwards has built up with Klopp is illustrated by how keen the former Borussia Dortmund manager was to have him occupy the sporting director role that he had been used to working under in Germany. No other candidates were interviewed and none were considered.

In Klopp's vision of Melwood being Liverpool's football headquarters he wanted someone whom he could trust and rely upon to work alongside and the Sheffield University graduate was his first and only choice. The pair now have offices within a few footsteps of one another at the club's training ground.

"This decision is hugely positive for us and it will make us better and stronger in managing the process of building and retaining playing talent at all age groups. Development is so important and it makes sense to have a position, within the football structure specifically, that focuses on where we can improve," Klopp said.

“It’s no secret I like the concept of a sporting director and having worked under this model previously I have found it to be nothing but positive and forward thinking.

“Michael is absolutely the right person for this. He has the knowledge, expertise and personality to flourish in the role and I was delighted when he told me he would be accepting the position.

“Importantly, he also has a fantastic team of people around him, who have all played a significant role in putting together the talent we currently have in the first team, development squad and at even younger age levels.”

With Ian Ayre, the chief executive, set to depart at the end of this season, Edwards will become the most senior football figure at Liverpool aside from Klopp. In preparation for his responsibilities being expanded, Edwards has worked alongside Ayre on transfer and contract negotiations for the last 18 months, playing a leading role in concluding deals to sign Mane, Joel Matip and Loris Karius and overseeing the sales of Christian Benteke, Jordon Ibe and Joe Allen.

Now Edwards is tasked with being the main man and with overseeing the rest of a restructuring programme that was signalled by his own promotion, and although Klopp will continue to have the final say on all transfers he believes a model which sees power shared within a group rather than focused entirely on the manager is in the best long term interests of the club.

“I’ve been proud to be part of the football operations structure here at Liverpool and it’s a great honour to be asked to lead it going forward, in this new role of sporting director," Edwards said.

"We have a brilliant team of people who all make a huge contribution to the process of player transfers and retention, together with recruitment for the senior team, development squad and our academy.

“Jürgen’s belief and confidence in what we have done is also welcomed and was a big factor in me making the decision to accept this position. It’s critical that we are always focused on development and improvement across all areas of the football operation. It’s an exciting challenge to be tasked with the responsibility of reviewing our practices and then implementing positive changes as and when they are needed. I know I’ll be supported by a brilliant group of people while doing this.”

Liverpool believe Edwards is ready for the tasks he faces and the incessant demands of the football industry mean he will be tested immediately.

The January transfer window opens in less than two months and having been thwarted in his pursuit of Christian Pulisic at the end of the last one, the strong likelihood is that Klopp would still like to add another wide attacker to his ranks. Then there is the matter of Philippe Coutinho's future with Barcelona and Paris St Germain both known to be monitoring a player who has arguably been the Premier League's best performer this season.

Issues like these are now Edwards' responsibility but he will deal with them in the knowledge that he has the full support of Klopp and the Liverpool hierarchy.

The other thing in Edwards' favour is timing. There is no better moment to be promoted and for your work to be highlighted than when the team is flying and Edwards' appointment coincides with Liverpool looking as strong as they have done for some time.

Making changes from a position of strength was another old Liverpool motif, one that served them well time and time again, and should it work as effectively this time the faith shown in Edwards by Gordon and Klopp will be rewarded.[/article]
 
Nah. Every photographer churns out a steaming turd of a shot every now and then regardless of how well they know their equipment or what level they are working at.
Oh absolutely - the public doesn't see the vast majority of shots that go in the rubbish bin, from every photographer that's ever been published !

The shot doesn't work - thanks to the issues you pointed out - but Powell shouldn't feel embarrassed for taking it, he should have thought twice before including it in his public portfolio though because it doesn't sit well with some other very well executed photos.
Yeah he should (feel embarrassed for taking it). He shoots for a living and takes group shots and portraits probably more than any other type - he could have easily avoided that (if changing lenses wasn't an option) by backing off 10 steps, shooting wide to avoid the distortion at the borders, getting a little lower and putting the group in the middle (again to avoid distortion), thereby enabling cropping (and on high MP cameras, as I'm sure he was using, that's not an issue) without the distortion and perspective issues. Huge embarrassment for a pro to have that online and associated with his name.

Anyway I'm sure I'm boring the arse off of everyone with this crap so I'll STFU now !
 
Why does anyone give a fuck about this?

Maybe because we're in touching distance of dominating the league again. And this guy might ruin it all in a single transfer window. You like historical data, the last times we came close both Houllier and Benitez totally fucked us with transfers.
 
Maybe because we're in touching distance of dominating the league again. And this guy might ruin it all in a single transfer window. You like historical data, the last times we came close both Houllier and Benitez totally fucked us with transfers.

But Klopp approved the appointment and has final say on all transfers.

So it shouldn't make that much difference, and the responsibility is still with the manager.

Now, if there was loads of evidence that he was some kind of deliriously incompetent and unqualified fuckwit, then I'd be more concerned. But we don't know that.
 
But Klopp approved the appointment and has final say on all transfers.

So it shouldn't make that much difference, and the responsibility is still with the manager.

Now, if there was loads of evidence that he was some kind of deliriously incompetent and unqualified fuckwit, then I'd be more concerned. But we don't know that.

There you go, I tend to adopt that as my default position upon people unless there is evidence to the contrary.
 
There you go, I tend to adopt that as my default position upon people unless there is evidence to the contrary.

Well, OK, but he's been at the club a while and seems to have impressed the owners and more importantly to me, the manager.

I don't really have much else to go on, so I'm still in the "don't fucking care" camp.
 
Because its good for the club?

Well, I suppose my point is more that nobody has any definitive proof how good he is, or isn't, or will be, or won't be.

So it's a hard thing to debate, given you can't exactly look at 2 minutes of his spreadsheet skills on Youtube.
 
Well, I suppose my point is more that nobody has any definitive proof how good he is, or isn't, or will be, or won't be.

So it's a hard thing to debate, given you can't exactly look at 2 minutes of his spreadsheet skills on Youtube.

Yeah, its to early to tell how it will work out but;

1) Klopp wants to work with him as our sporting director
2) We'll have a more solid base going forward like Dortmund, Soton, Sevilla etc were we can change managers but dont have to change everything else with the set up.
3) As Klopp pointed out quicker decisions can be made about players, contracts and transfers
4) The first transfer window was very good. Lets hope it continues that way.
 
It's an interesting appointment. I quite like the promotion from within aspect, based on the assumption that he should be able to hit the ground running. I do have some reservations about his experience level and we have no clear idea which successes or failures he has backed in the past.

At the very least, whether "Eddie" is the right guy or not (I hope he is), I am pleased that we are once again looking at this type of structure.


Promotion from within troubles me greatly.

It suggests that he's not there on merit, but because he has earned the favour of the insiders who matter through friendship or mutual favours, and/or has eliminated those who dislike him. A worse possibility is that the owners are too lazy or inexperienced to find someone better.

Almost no one good in our management structure has emerged by being 'promoted from within'.
I smell troubled waters ahead.
 
Agreed. Which is a good sign. There doesnt seem to be any internal conflicy going on as there were during Rodgers tenure.
 
Agreed. Which is a good sign. There doesnt seem to be any internal conflicy going on as there were during Rodgers tenure.

Yeah, I'd be quite interested to find out a bit more about "Eddie" and Rodgers' relationship

I hope it wasn't all about Balotelli, because if that WAS down to Eddie, then he's a fucking moron.
 
If Edwards works out well for the club, I fully expect Comolli to come out with some statement to take full credit for his original signing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom