Except he was.
Gerrard, Hamman, Alonso are the the only three I would put above him, and all three of them were world class.
He was a brilliant brilliant DM.
Beyond those 3, who else have we had in the last 25 years? Redknapp, Lucas, whomever..? Hardly an illustrious list mate.
Besides, I always felt he was hugely overrated. I could see why fans took to him; he was passionate, ran around like a mentalist, jumped into tackles, slide about on his arse a lot, and looked feroccious n shit. But for me he gave away far too many free-kicks, he took himself out of the game too often by going to ground, and his passing was limited. He got lucky he was playing alongside Alonso and Gerrard.
Average workhorse midfielder. Gattuso really.