Or rather, well done him!We’ll done him.
Or rather, well done him!We’ll done him.
I’d reluctantly sell for 100m, only because I dont trust these owners to improve the squad.Let's be honest, if PSG offered between £80-100m, how many of us would sell? Before someone asks where I get my value from, I am using Harry Kane as the yard stick here.
I wouldn’t. No chance.Let's be honest, if PSG offered between £80-100m, how many of us would sell? Before someone asks where I get my value from, I am using Harry Kane as the yard stick here.
Again this is a lazy view. He’s made the difference so many times and significantly more than anyone else in our team.Definitely much better but he has been poor for most the season rarely making a difference. We could could point to other issues afflicting team— somebody up thread rightly mentioned the poor quality of the final ball— but we’d not be in this disruption had he been moved consistent this term.
Well done him.
Definitely much better but he has been poor for most the season rarely making a difference. We could could point to other issues afflicting team— somebody up thread rightly mentioned the poor quality of the final ball— but we’d not be in this disruption had he been moved consistent this term.
We’ll done him.
Prove it and remember that everyone else is so much less than him.Again this is a lazy view. He’s made the difference so many times and significantly more than anyone else in our team.
I just did above. Look at how often he has made the difference in games this season and then ask yourself if saying he seldom made the difference is a lazy view? It’s simply not true or even remotely close to the truth.Prove it and remember that everyone else is so much less than him.
Apart from all the examples I’ve laid out above I’m not sure how someone who’s scores 33% of all our goals and had 25% of all our assists cannot be classified as carrying the team.I've been begging Salah to hit some form all season. A purple patch I said, would probably get us 4th. Too little, too late.
Now that the rest of the team is more sorted, we brought Gakpo in, etc. etc. he has some sort of platform and his form has improved. That for me, is not carrying the team.
I've been begging Salah to hit some form all season. A purple patch I said, would probably get us 4th. Too little, too late.
Now that the rest of the team is more sorted, we brought Gakpo in, etc. etc. he has some sort of platform and his form has improved. That for me, is not carrying the team.
Great post.I don't scapegoat Salah, I ask more of him because he's one of our best players, and this whole debate for me was centered around the question of whether we should keep him or not, given our needs.
Allison is the only player we've had all season that has shown any degree of consistency. That's not just my opinion, it's Klopps. If Salah has had consistent form all season and carried us through the bad times, why did Klopp take pains to address the difficulties he had in playing in a new look forward line that wasn't as productive for him? Why did he only have 7 league goals halfway through the season?
Salah is doing much better now, but for me showed no adaptability or leadership when asked to do some stuff he'd rather not do as much. When the goals weren't coming, and we weren't playing well, I think he was often detrimental to the team. For me, that isn't carrying a team, but rather amplifying both strengths and weaknesses. Which is fair enough, many strikers are like that. Most of them. On the range of "sulky cunt" to "finds a way" Salah is better than most, but is also still a human. I'm only pushing back on the idea that he has "carried the team this season" because it was introduced by someone else.
I never was interested in having a discussion about whether Salah was good, nor a revisiting of that discussion every time he fucking scored a goal, missed a penalty or played a game. I am not particularly interested in assigning blame for a season where there's plenty to go around, and much of it has to go the players that weren't here, rather than those that are. He has limitations, he has many strengths. We've found a way for one of best players to play better, and he's also playing better. I don't think he found that way himself.
You could say the same of Trent, but both of these shifts involve us having other players in. Gakpo's introduction for instance has solved so much, and involved Gakpo changing his game and learning very quickly.
TBF our performances dramatically improved with Jones and Trent joining the midfield, as well as gakpo finding his feet as a false 9. It allowed fabinho to conserve more energy, meaning more effective performances, and allowed hendo to either get a rest or be on the ball less.
A more concrete midfield, backed up by the false 9 allowed our forwards to be in their natural positions, rather than half worrying about putting fires out in mid.
I don't think our performances suffer with Darwin on the pitch, they suffer from the lack of false 9
We've looked sharper and more coherent with Jota and Gakpo in the front 3 than at any point with Nunez.
I actually agree... but, if this forum was anything to go by, "hit the ground running" is a massive stretch.That's my point. Jota knows how to work with a false 9 as he's been here for 3 years, whereas when we start Nunez it's either 1) the team doesn't know how to play with a 9, or 2) Nunez doesn't know how to work with the false 9 yet.
Gakpo has come in and hit the ground running because ultimately, he's played across the front 3 for a few years, so is inherently versatile. Nunez is still learning the system, as well as when to press.
Considering he's scored as many as he has when he's been used relatively sparingly, in a dysfunctional team and not knowing how we play; I think there's a lot to be hopeful for
First 7 games, 0 goals, 0 assists.I actually agree... but, if this forum was anything to go by, "hit the ground running" is a massive stretch.
Like I say, I agree
I watch every game. He was completely fucking rubbish first 3 games then slowly improved. He looked completely out of place in the EPL.Did you actually watch any of those 7 games though?
The signs of class was there....the link up play was there....the elegant touches were there, he wasn't just some smuck that looked out of pace, physically inept etc.
It's amazing to think that if he didn't dribble into blind alleys or shoot from stupid angles with others in better position, he'd probably have 30+ assists a season.