[quote author=Wizardry link=topic=36802.msg973972#msg973972 date=1256768382]
[quote author=dossena link=topic=36802.msg973952#msg973952 date=1256767683]
[quote author=Wizardry link=topic=36802.msg973944#msg973944 date=1256767370]
[quote author=Farkmaster link=topic=36802.msg973928#msg973928 date=1256766923]
[quote author=Wizardry link=topic=36802.msg973916#msg973916 date=1256766707]
Signing him while injured for this season looks the biggest gamble I've ever seen Rafa take. I hope it pays off.
[/quote]
I thought signing Babel for 11M was his biggest gamble and said so at the time. Let's hope this plays out better.
[/quote]
Yeah, that looks a huge gamble now. But the timing of this one is remarkable; the season after we make only our second title challenge in nearly 20 years he sells one of the best passers in the league, a player integral to our great performance, and buys an unproven Italian for close to our record transfer............ and does so while the player is injured.
He's got a lot to lose considering the thoughts and hopes of the fans at the end of last season.
One other thing from this match....... bloody hell Degen has got some acceleration. I couldn't quite work out what his top pace was but his ability to go from 20% to about (presumably) 95% was jaw dropping. If he had a cross like Finnan we could use him at RM/RW.
[/quote]
Regardless of where we finished the previous season, I think it was more like Xabi wanted to leave, and Rafa was trying to find the best value for money replacement.
[/quote]
Rafa made Xabi's mind up for him with his treatment the previous season. It was up to Rafa to step in and change his mind - which he clearly didn't do. The Xabi of two seasons ago loved Liverpool with a heart felt passion - you don't lose that because of a bad experience with a manager; it just has to be re-kindled.
Xabi definitely wanted to leave and give a nice little "fuck-you" gesture to Rafa by doing it after such a great season. It was up to Rafa to convince him to stay IMO. Can you imagine Sir Bob or Shanks watching as one of their top 3 players left in a seriously pissed off way because of the treatment they received?
Having said all that it's the decision to sign Aquilani that is the big part of the gamble. I can't believe how desperate I am for him to hit the ground running and provide that class which will release both Gerrard and Torres.
[/quote]
The first paragraph was really your take on what might have happened. For all we know, Rafa could've offered Montse to Xabi, in exchange of him staying.
The fact of the matter is, that Rafa has publicly stated that he wanted Xabi to stay. Xabi wanted to join the galacticos. We didn't have that much money and Barry has fucked off to City. Rafa then assessed his options, then decided that Aquilani at a discount price was the best value.
I agree that it is a gamble, but I think that it was forced to him by Xabi wanting to leave and us having no dosh.