Now I’m unfortunately going to sound a lot like Modo in this thread, but this is something Klopp needs to seriously think about.
Since his arrival, Henderson has been first-choice DM / holding mid, and Can has played in a variety of positions.
When Henderson has been available, Can has either played as one of the two more advanced CMs in the 4-3-3, or occasionally in defence.
When Henderson’s absent however, Klopp goes with Can at DM / holding mid. I’ve made this point several times before, but we’re just a far better side when Henderson is absent and Can is playing
DM.
Let’s look at some basic evidence.
2015/16
Henderson missed 15 games from September-November through injury. Can ended up as DM in a majority of those games. We lost just 1 of those 15 games.
He then missed 11 games through injury again from April-May. Can came in at DM again, and played probably the best football of his LFC career as we went on that Europa League run, beating Dortmund and Villareal. 2 defeats in those 11 games.
2016/17
Henderson missed 13 games. Can came into that DM role. We took 27 points from 13 games to secure 4th place.
Also, let’s look at our worst defensive performances under Klopp (conceding 3 goals or more).
That’s happened 14 times in Klopp’s reign. Henderson has started at DM in 10 of those 14 games. Can has been DM in two of those games.
I know our defensive blues are largely attributable to our horrendous defenders. But this record from our DM / holding mid is totally unacceptable. The DM is the one who needs to take responsibility and stem the flow when the side is under a lot of attacking pressure. Henderson is utterly inept at this. He’s proven this time and again.
Henderson’s best position is as an attacking CM in a 4-3-3, the kind of role he played in the 13-14 season, which was the best football he’s played for Liverpool. If his injuries have rendered him incapable of playing that role, then we need to stop shoehorning him into the midfield just because he’s captain. He’s not a good DM. In fact, he’s a terrible one. If we need to strip of him captaincy to get him away from that position, then so be it.