If the transfer rumours were accurate, our scouting department/ transfer committee did spot the likes of Dembele, Mor and Guerrerio.
While it's good not to settle for 2nd best or poorer alternatives, the stubbornness/persistence to be 'devoted'/focused in the chase for a particular player can be dangerous.
Zieliński is an example and perhaps Dahoud (to a lesser extent) is another. Following/chasing the player for an extended period of time and eventually failing to wrap up the signing.
It is admirable of Klopp to believe in coaching and improving players and not over-indulge in signings players as a simple solution to getting results but we should also consider factors such as the position we are in (league position, progress in cup competitions, injuries/suspensions etc.) and the competition we are facing for the targets at the point in time.
How sure are we that we will be able to land the likes of Brandt and Pulisic in the summer to forgo other feasible targets/be reluctant to pay slightly over the odds for them now? Clubs who are well stocked in the relevant departments are less likely to join in the chase whereas competition is sure to increase in the summer. Then, let's say we suffer due to the lack of strength in depth and options and fail to make it for CL next season, surely that'll hurt our chances of landing intended targets further?
Besides, is it really bad to have alternative choices when chasing a signing for a particular position? Surely that's logical? It is up to the scouting department and transfer committee to make sure that the candidates on the list are of as high a calibre as possible.
*Edit. This was what Monchi said in last year's interview with Guardian.
[article]Monchi pulls out his phone and, carefully reducing the image so the names can’t be seen, says: “That gives us this.” A colour-coded spreadsheet shows players by position. Around 250 potential targets, in all positions. “The manager says: ‘I want a left-back who averages 11km a game, runs 800m at full speed, uses both feet.’ And from these, 10 will fit.”
Negotiations come next, where you have to know the market, have an alternative, and be realistic. “The guy selling a Seat Leon will claim it’s a better model,” Monchi says. “Kanouté wasn’t the first option; we were going after Fred, the Brazilian. We wanted [Kevin-Prince] Boateng before Keita. And if a player says: ‘Chelsea want me,’ I say: ‘What are you talking to me for, then?’ But if Swansea or Spurs want you, let’s talk. I sell the city, the club: a serious club that pays as promised, which sounds trivial but isn’t.”
There’s no guarantee, of course. “After a month [Yevhen] Konoplyanka wanted to throw himself off the balcony. I try to really know the player but there are always surprises. Grzegorz Krychowiak, aged 19. You think: ‘What’s a Pole going to be like here?’ But it turns out he’s the most sevillano bloke ever. Arouna Koné was our most expensive signing and scored two in 41; he goes to Levante, a ‘weaker’ team, and scores 17.”
[/article]