[quote author=paulie187 link=topic=27188.msg681068#msg681068 date=1222093097]
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=27188.msg681060#msg681060 date=1222092537]
[quote author=paulie187 link=topic=27188.msg681056#msg681056 date=1222092295]
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=27188.msg681051#msg681051 date=1222092040]
[quote author=paulie187 link=topic=27188.msg681050#msg681050 date=1222091971]
We need our attacking players to score more than 3 goals between them in 5 league games.
By your reasoning Rebel, we should drop Carragher, as he's not getting enougb goals
[/quote]
we should drop one of them and play Agger in games against the likes of Stoke, WBA, Hull etc. there aren't many threats apart from set pieces, no world class strikers to contain.
when your attackers are off you need a defender to grab a goal, one proven player at scoring goals in a Liverpool shirt against premiership teams like Chelsea, Arsenal and West Ham is Agger
our CBs need to be pushing up and popping up in the box in games like this, making the extra number.
[/quote]
So you want to put a centre-half into the team who hasn't played a league in 13 months for no reason other than he 'scores goals'. Fantastic reasoning
[/quote]
what is wrong with that? he is fit and played for the danes, stoke are fucking shit and Agger would have been like an extra midfielder and would have helped in pressuring them. you look at all our rivals they have defenders who will grab or be involved in VITAL goals, that's why we need Agger
[/quote]
Your basing your whole arguement on Aggers goal against West Ham which was an absolute peach. That was a complete one off, and while we probably won't see Carra do that , I'd have him in my team over Agger every day of the week
How would Skrtel feel if he was dropped for not scoring enough goals? He's been excellent, one of our most solid players but now you want him dropped?
[/quote]
my whole argument isnt based on that goal against West ham its based on Aggers ability on the ball, at bringing it forward, at stepping into midfield, at taking occasional attacking responsibility like none of our other CBs can, at playing passes and yes, scoring goals against the likes of Chelsea (from set pieces). these qualities make him useful to the side especially against teams at home who offer little in attack and where we're expected to have most of the possession
Skrtel or Carra should be dropped for him in those cases no matter how well they play, who cares how they feel, we should use players in games where they're suited, that's the reason for having a big squad
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=27188.msg681060#msg681060 date=1222092537]
[quote author=paulie187 link=topic=27188.msg681056#msg681056 date=1222092295]
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=27188.msg681051#msg681051 date=1222092040]
[quote author=paulie187 link=topic=27188.msg681050#msg681050 date=1222091971]
We need our attacking players to score more than 3 goals between them in 5 league games.
By your reasoning Rebel, we should drop Carragher, as he's not getting enougb goals
[/quote]
we should drop one of them and play Agger in games against the likes of Stoke, WBA, Hull etc. there aren't many threats apart from set pieces, no world class strikers to contain.
when your attackers are off you need a defender to grab a goal, one proven player at scoring goals in a Liverpool shirt against premiership teams like Chelsea, Arsenal and West Ham is Agger
our CBs need to be pushing up and popping up in the box in games like this, making the extra number.
[/quote]
So you want to put a centre-half into the team who hasn't played a league in 13 months for no reason other than he 'scores goals'. Fantastic reasoning
[/quote]
what is wrong with that? he is fit and played for the danes, stoke are fucking shit and Agger would have been like an extra midfielder and would have helped in pressuring them. you look at all our rivals they have defenders who will grab or be involved in VITAL goals, that's why we need Agger
[/quote]
Your basing your whole arguement on Aggers goal against West Ham which was an absolute peach. That was a complete one off, and while we probably won't see Carra do that , I'd have him in my team over Agger every day of the week
How would Skrtel feel if he was dropped for not scoring enough goals? He's been excellent, one of our most solid players but now you want him dropped?
[/quote]
my whole argument isnt based on that goal against West ham its based on Aggers ability on the ball, at bringing it forward, at stepping into midfield, at taking occasional attacking responsibility like none of our other CBs can, at playing passes and yes, scoring goals against the likes of Chelsea (from set pieces). these qualities make him useful to the side especially against teams at home who offer little in attack and where we're expected to have most of the possession
Skrtel or Carra should be dropped for him in those cases no matter how well they play, who cares how they feel, we should use players in games where they're suited, that's the reason for having a big squad