• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

The 2010/11 Player of the Season game.

Forums Unread posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Morse

Morse

Very Active
Honorary Member
The Liverpool Supporters’ Player of the Season game.

Hello everyone.

Some of you may know me. I am a visitor to quite a few LFC sites and have been the custodian of the player of the season game for 6 years now. The game has spanned many different sites in its time and last year the main voters came from Est1892, 6CM, Scouser Tommy, TLW and YNWA. I am hoping that more voters from other sites will give a more accurate picture of our feelings as Liverpool supporters.

I am hoping that you will play a part in this 7th year to enable us to get a picture of our players’ performances and to crown a worthy winner come May 2011.

Previous winners:

2005 – Jamie Carragher
2006 – Steven Gerrard
2007 – Dirk Kuyt
2008 – Javier Mascherano
2009 – Xabi Alonso
2010 - Javier Mascherano


This year, the format will be the same. Instead of voting for a single player as your Man of the match, you vote for your top 3. This enables a “steady Eddie†like Reina or Kuyt to get his mentions and gain some points. (I did think about a top 5 list, but can foresee problems when the result goes against us…getting people to vote for 1 player is hard enough!)

Points are the same as last year, top player gets 5 points, second player gets 3 and third player gets a single point.
I will award a bonus point if our Goalkeeper keeps a clean sheet.

All competitive games are counted, CC, FA, ELQs, EL and Premier League matches.

I shall post current league tables so that we can follow the players’ performances throughout the season.

Hopefully, the tables will put an end to the “Babel is shite†type of arguments.

If a moderator could ensure a sticky when I post a Man of the Match thread, I would be grateful…also it would be nice if I could have a sticky league table thread for the game throughout the season.

Thanks for your support in this.

YNWA.
 
2008 – Javier Mascherano
2009 – Xabi Alonso
2010 - Javier Mascherano

And people wonder why I might be withholding judgment on this season until I see what CM we bring in?

And thanks for your work Morse, I always enjoy this.
 
Is it right to give the goalie an extra point for a clean sheet?

The rest of the team also have something to say about not conceding.
 
[quote author=Morse link=topic=41206.msg1145734#msg1145734 date=1280511013]

Hopefully, the tables will put an end to the Babel is shite†type of arguments.


YNWA.
[/quote]

Well Said Morse.
Surely there cannot be anyone left that thinks that Babel is anything more than useless 😉


Thanks for this BTW.
While not exactly a frequent contributer I usually enjoy reading the threads.
 
[quote author=keniget link=topic=41206.msg1145754#msg1145754 date=1280513805]
Is it right to give the goalie an extra point for a clean sheet?

The rest of the team also have something to say about not conceding.
[/quote]

True, but the keeper's less likely to get votes for it than most outfield players, so this is just a way of trying to redress that balance. Witness last season when, big Masher fan though I've always been, even I would concede Pepe should have won this.
 
Result: Game 1 - Rabotnicki - Away - ELQ

1. Ngog...............................269 votes.........................5 points
2. Kelly................................122 votes.........................3 points
3. Lucas................................73 votes.........................1 point

Bonus point for clean sheet.......................Cavalieri..........1 point.


Current standings:

1. Ngog.........................1 MOM....................................5 points
2. Kelly..........................1 2nd.....................................3 points
3. Lucas........................1 3rd......................................1 point
4. Cavalieri.....................1 Bonus..................................1 point


Thanks for voting.
 
Result: Game 2 - Rabotnicki - Home - ELQ

I am happy that our fellow LFC site "Irish Kop" have joined our voting for this season.
I hope they enjoy following the progress of the game.

1. Cole...................................................580 votes.......................................5 points
2. Gerrard..............................................223 votes.......................................3 points
3. Kelly...................................................183 votes........................................1 point.

4. Jovanovic..........................................128 votes........................................Unlucky Milan.

Bonus point for Cavalieri for the clean sheet.


All sites voted Joe Cole as MOM. Hopefully the first of many.
6CM and TLW had it as above.
YNWA and IK had Jovanovic 3rd.
ST had Kelly 2nd and Jovanovic 3rd.
Est1892 had Jovanovic 2nd and Gerrard 3rd.


Current standings:

1. Cole...........................1 MOM...................................5 points
2. Ngog.........................1 MOM....................................5 points
3. Kelly...........................1 2nd..........1 3rd..................4 points
4. Gerrard......................1 2nd.....................................3 points
5. Cavalieri....................2 Bonus.................................2 points
6. Lucas.........................1 3rd......................................1 point



Thanks for voting.
 
Result: Arsenal - Home - PL

1. Mascherano....................................................634 votes.....................................5 points
2. Skrtel................................................................413 votes.....................................3 points
3. Ngog................................................................269 votes......................................1 point.
No Goal keeping bonus.

All sites had Mascher and Skrtel top 2 apart from IK who had Carra 2nd.
ST and 6CM had Gerrard 3rd.
Est1892 and TLW had Ngog 3rd.
YNWA had Carra 3rd.
IK had Skrtel 3rd.


Current standings:

1. Ngog.........................1 MOM.........1 3rd..................6 points
2. Mascherano.............1 MOM....................................5 points
3. Cole...........................1 MOM...................................5 points
4. Kelly...........................1 2nd..........1 3rd..................4 points
5. Skrtel..........................1 2nd.....................................3 points
6. Gerrard......................1 2nd.....................................3 points
7. Cavalieri....................2 Bonus.................................2 points
8. Lucas.........................1 3rd......................................1 point



Thanks for voting.
 
[quote author=keniget link=topic=41206.msg1145754#msg1145754 date=1280513805]
Is it right to give the goalie an extra point for a clean sheet?

The rest of the team also have something to say about not conceding.
[/quote]I don't think we need worry too much about this Ken.
 
[quote author=Herr Onceared link=topic=41206.msg1161915#msg1161915 date=1282741114]
[quote author=keniget link=topic=41206.msg1145754#msg1145754 date=1280513805]
Is it right to give the goalie an extra point for a clean sheet?

The rest of the team also have something to say about not conceding.
[/quote]I don't think we need worry too much about this Ken.
[/quote]

Haha, quite.

+10 points if the LB scores a hatrick of over-head kicks

+30 if N'gog learns to fly.
 
[quote author=Squiggles link=topic=41206.msg1161956#msg1161956 date=1282744019]
[quote author=Herr Onceared link=topic=41206.msg1161915#msg1161915 date=1282741114]
[quote author=keniget link=topic=41206.msg1145754#msg1145754 date=1280513805]
Is it right to give the goalie an extra point for a clean sheet?

The rest of the team also have something to say about not conceding.
[/quote]I don't think we need worry too much about this Ken.
[/quote]

Haha, quite.

+10 points if the LB scores a hatrick of over-head kicks

+30 if N'gog learns to fly.
[/quote]Someone turns invisible +30 points...........oh well done Lucas.
 
[quote author=Farkmaster link=topic=41206.msg1145744#msg1145744 date=1280511943]
2008 – Javier Mascherano
2009 – Xabi Alonso
2010 - Javier Mascherano

And people wonder why I might be withholding judgment on this season until I see what CM we bring in?

And thanks for your work Morse, I always enjoy this.
[/quote]

Don't think you were asked to pronounce judgement on the entire season yet... Just how things were Vs previous expectations at a particular point in time.
 
Result: Game 4 - Trabzon - Home - EL

1. Kyrgiakos....................................................345 votes.................................5 points
2. Jovanovic....................................................255 votes.................................3 points
3. Reina.............................................................86 votes..................................1 point.
Bonus point for Reina for the clean sheet.


6CM, TLW and IK had it as above.
Est1892 had Kelly in 3rd.
ST had Poulson 2nd and Jova 3rd.
YNWA had Jova as MOM, with Soto 2nd and then Lucas.


Current standings:

1. Ngog.........................1 MOM.........1 3rd..................6 points
2. Kyrgiakos.................1 MOM....................................5 points
3. Mascherano.............1 MOM....................................5 points
4. Cole...........................1 MOM...................................5 points
5. Kelly...........................1 2nd..........1 3rd..................4 points
6. Jovanovic..................1 2nd......................................3 points
7. Skrtel..........................1 2nd.....................................3 points
8. Gerrard......................1 2nd.....................................3 points
9. Reina.........................1 3rd..........1 Bonus.............2 points
10.Cavalieri...................2 Bonus................................2 points
11.Lucas........................1 3rd......................................1 point



Thanks for voting.
 
Result: Game 5 - Manchester City - Away - PL

1. Gerrard.................................................390 votes.......................................5 points
2. Carragher.............................................135 votes......................................3 points
3. Torres......................................................81 votes.......................................1 point.

No Goal Keeping bonus.

ST, TLW and IK all voted as above.
Est1892 voted Ngog 3rd.
6CM voted Babel 3rd.
YNWA Torres 2nd and Babel 3rd.


Current standings:

1. Gerrard......................1 MOM........1 2nd.................8 points
2. Ngog.........................1 MOM.........1 3rd..................6 points
3. Kyrgiakos.................1 MOM....................................5 points
4. Mascherano.............1 MOM....................................5 points
5. Cole...........................1 MOM...................................5 points
6. Kelly...........................1 2nd..........1 3rd..................4 points
7. Carragher.................1 2nd......................................3 points
8. Jovanovic..................1 2nd......................................3 points
9. Skrtel..........................1 2nd.....................................3 points
10.Reina.........................1 3rd..........1 Bonus.............2 points
11.Cavalieri...................2 Bonus................................2 points
12.Torres.......................1 3rd.......................................1 point
13.Lucas........................1 3rd.......................................1 point



Thanks for voting.
 
Result: Game 6 - Trabzon - Away - EL

1. Johnson..............................................171 votes...................................5 points
2. Ngog....................................................100 votes...................................3 points
3. Kelly........................................................98 votes....................................1 point
4. Pacheco.................................................75 votes...................................Unlucky.

No clean sheet bonus.

A difficult one with no site agreeing.
YNWA had Kelly, Ngog and Johnson.
Est 1892 had Kelly, Pacheco and Ngog.
ST had Ngog, Reina and Kyrgiakos.
6CM had Johnson, Kelly and Pacheco.
TLW had Johnson, Kuyt and Pacheco.
IK had Johnson, Pacheco and Kelly.


Current standings:

1. Ngog.........................1 MOM.........1 2nd........1 3rd....9 points
2. Gerrard......................1 MOM........1 2nd.....................8 points
3. Johnson....................1 MOM........................................5 points
4. Kyrgiakos.................1 MOM.........................................5 points
5. Mascherano.............1 MOM........................................5 points
6. Cole...........................1 MOM........................................5 points
7. Kelly...........................1 2nd..........2 3rd.......................5 points
8. Carragher.................1 2nd..........................................3 points
9. Jovanovic..................1 2nd..........................................3 points
10.Skrtel..........................1 2nd........................................3 points
11.Reina.........................1 3rd..........1 Bonus................2 points
12.Cavalieri...................2 Bonus....................................2 points
13.Torres.......................1 3rd...........................................1 point
14.Lucas........................1 3rd...........................................1 point



Thanks for voting.
 
Result: Game 7 - WBA - Home - PL

1. Torres...................................................288 votes..................................5 points
2. Kuyt.......................................................210 votes..................................3 points
3. Reina......................................................91 votes...................................1 point.
Goalkeeping bonus.................................Reina........................................1 point.


No site agreed with the above.
TLW and IK had Poulson 3rd.
6CM had Skrtel 2nd and Gerrard 3rd.
Est1892 had Reina 2nd and Kuyt 3rd.
YNWA had Kuyt as MOM, with Torres then Lucas.
ST had Kuyt as MOM, with Torres then Gerrard.


Current standings:

1. Ngog.........................1 MOM.........1 2nd........1 3rd....9 points
2. Gerrard......................1 MOM........1 2nd.....................8 points
3. Torres.......................1 MOM.........1 3rd.....................6 points
4. Johnson....................1 MOM........................................5 points
5. Kyrgiakos.................1 MOM.........................................5 points
6. Mascherano.............1 MOM........................................5 points
7. Cole...........................1 MOM........................................5 points
8. Kelly...........................1 2nd..........2 3rd.......................5 points
9. Reina.........................2 3rd..........2 Bonus................4 points
10.Kuyt............................1 2nd..........................................3 points
11.Carragher.................1 2nd..........................................3 points
12.Jovanovic..................1 2nd..........................................3 points
13.Skrtel..........................1 2nd........................................3 points
14.Cavalieri...................2 Bonus....................................2 points
15.Lucas........................1 3rd...........................................1 point



Thanks for voting.
 
[quote author=Herr Onceared link=topic=41206.msg1162837#msg1162837 date=1282844505]
[quote author=Squiggles link=topic=41206.msg1161956#msg1161956 date=1282744019]
[quote author=Herr Onceared link=topic=41206.msg1161915#msg1161915 date=1282741114]
[quote author=keniget link=topic=41206.msg1145754#msg1145754 date=1280513805]
Is it right to give the goalie an extra point for a clean sheet?

The rest of the team also have something to say about not conceding.
[/quote]I don't think we need worry too much about this Ken.
[/quote]

Haha, quite.

+10 points if the LB scores a hatrick of over-head kicks

+30 if N'gog learns to fly.
[/quote]Someone turns invisible +30 points...........oh well done Lucas.
[/quote]

Explains how he did so well in this last year!
 
Result: Game 8 - Birmingham City - Away - Pl


1. Reina..................................................675 votes...................................5 points
2. Konchesky.........................................234 votes...................................3 points
3. Carragher..........................................125 votes....................................1 point.
Clean Sheet bonus point...........................................................................Reina.


Every single voter had Pepe as their Man of the Match...amazing.
ST, 6CM, TLW and IK voted as above.
Est1892 had Gerrard 3rd.
YNWA had Gerrard 2nd and Meireles 3rd.


Current standings:

1. Reina.........................1 MOM........2 3rd..........3 Bonus.......10 points
2. Ngog.........................1 MOM.........1 2nd.........1 3rd...............9 points
3. Gerrard......................1 MOM........1 2nd.................................8 points
4. Torres.......................1 MOM.........1 3rd..................................6 points
5. Johnson....................1 MOM...................................................5 points
6. Kyrgiakos.................1 MOM....................................................5 points
7. Mascherano.............1 MOM...................................................5 points
8. Cole...........................1 MOM...................................................5 points
9. Kelly...........................1 2nd..........2 3rd..................................5 points
10.Carragher.................1 2nd.........1 3rd..................................4 points
11.Konchesky...............1 2nd.....................................................3 points
12.Kuyt............................1 2nd....................................................3 points
13.Jovanovic..................1 2nd....................................................3 points
14.Skrtel..........................1 2nd...................................................3 points
15.Cavalieri...................2 Bonus................................................2 points
16.Lucas........................1 3rd.......................................................1 point



Thanks for voting.
 
Result: Game 9 - Steaua Bucharest - Home - EL


1. Cole................................................523 votes........................................5 points
2. Ngog...............................................248 votes........................................3 points
3. Meireles.........................................194 votes.........................................1 point
4. Spearing........................................177 votes.........................................Unlucky.
No clean sheet bonus.

All sites had Joe Cole as MOM.
ST had it as above.
Est1892 and IK had Ngog 2nd and Spearing 3rd.
6CM had Ngog 2nd and Kelly 3rd.
YNWA had Meireles 2nd and Ngog 3rd.
TLW had Spearing 2nd and Ngog 3rd.


Current standings:

1. Ngog.........................1 MOM.........2 2nd.........1 3rd..............12 points
2. Cole...........................2 MOM...................................................10 points
3. Reina.........................1 MOM........2 3rd..........3 Bonus........10 points
4. Gerrard......................1 MOM........1 2nd.................................8 points
5. Torres.......................1 MOM.........1 3rd..................................6 points
6. Johnson....................1 MOM............................................... ....5 points
7. Kyrgiakos.................1 MOM............................................... .....5 points
8. Mascherano.............1 MOM............................................... ....5 points
9. Kelly...........................1 2nd..........2 3rd..................................5 points
10.Carragher.................1 2nd.........1 3rd..................................4 points
11.Konchesky...............1 2nd............................................... ......3 points
12.Kuyt............................1 2nd............................................... .....3 points
13.Jovanovic..................1 2nd............................................... .....3 points
14.Skrtel..........................1 2nd............................................... ....3 points
15.Cavalieri...................2 Bonus............................................. ...2 points
16.Meireles....................1 3rd.......................................................1 point
17.Lucas........................1 3rd............................................... ........1 point



Thanks for voting.
 
Result: Game 10 - Manchester United - Away - PL


1. Gerrard.................................................582 votes.................................5 points
2. Meireles...............................................366 votes.................................3 points
3. Poulson................................................150 votes.................................1 point.
No clean sheet bonus.

Est1892 and IK both voted as above.
YNWA had Torres 3rd.
ST had Cole 3rd.
6CM had Poulson 2nd and Meireles 3rd.
TLW had Meireles as MOM, with Gerrard 2nd and Poulson 3rd.

Current standings:

1. Gerrard......................2 MOM........1 2nd.................................13 points
2. Ngog.........................1 MOM.........2 2nd.........1 3rd..............12 points
3. Cole...........................2 MOM............................................... ....10 points
4. Reina.........................1 MOM........2 3rd..........3 Bonus........10 points
5. Torres.......................1 MOM.........1 3rd..................................6 points
6. Johnson....................1 MOM............................................... ....5 points
7. Kyrgiakos.................1 MOM............................................... .....5 points
8. Mascherano.............1 MOM............................................... ....5 points
9. Kelly...........................1 2nd..........2 3rd..................................5 points
10.Meireles....................1 2nd.........1 3rd...................................4 points
11.Carragher.................1 2nd.........1 3rd..................................4 points
12.Konchesky...............1 2nd............................................... ......3 points
13.Kuyt............................1 2nd............................................... .....3 points
14.Jovanovic..................1 2nd............................................... .....3 points
15.Skrtel..........................1 2nd............................................... ....3 points
16.Cavalieri...................2 Bonus............................................. ...2 points
17.Poulson.....................1 3rd......................................................1 point
18.Lucas........................1 3rd............................................... ........1 point



Thanks for voting.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom