Rate these managers

[Fox]

in order of brilliance in management

Wenger
Ferguson
Capello
Rafa
Mourinho
Lippi
Van Gaal
Hiddick
Ancelotti
Redknapp
sven
Rijkaard


have I forgotten anyone (too soon for pep G), trophies won not directly a reason folks

 

[Oncy]

Capello
Ferguson
Wenger
Lippi
Mourinho
Rafa
Hiddink
Van gaal
Ancelotti
rikjard
sven

 

[spider-Neil]

Ferguson
Capello
Wenger
Mourinho
Rafa
Ancelotti
Rijkaard
Lippi
Van Gaal
Hiddick
sven
Redknapp

 

[KingDing]

Capello
Ferguson
Hiddick
Wenger
Mourinho
Rafa
Lippi
Van Gaal
Ancelotti
Rijkaard
Redknapp
sven

 

[dossena]

Mourinho
Ferguson
Capello
Wenger
Hiddink
Rafa
Rijkaard


I'm not sure about the rest..

 

[SaRed]

Ferguson
Capello
Mourinho
Rafa
Van Gaal
Lippi
Ancelotti
Hiddink
Rijkaard
Sven
Redknapp (why is he in this list?)

 

[peterhague]

what's redknapp doing in there?


the top 3 are lippi, fegie-cunt, and capello.

the bottom 1 is redknapp.

 

[vikas]

Ferguson
Capello
Lippi
Wenger
Rafa
Mourinho
Hiddink
Ancelotti
Sven
Rijkaard
Van Gaal

 

[Fox]

ha ha had to have an englishman in there, come on harry

I am surprised Hiddink is not higher on most lists

 

[Mors]

Good, average and shit.

There ya go, done it.

 

[grjt]

Ferguson
Wenger
Capello
Rafa
Hiddink
Mourinho
Van Gaal
Ancelotti
Lippi
Redknapp
sven
Rijkaard

 

[Jürgen4PM]

Ferguson
Rafa
Capello
Mourinho
Wenger
Lippi
Hiddink
Ancelotti
Van gaal
Rikjard
Sven

 

[spider-Neil]

[quote author=grjt link=topic=36114.msg952767#msg952767 date=1254139518]
Ferguson
Wenger
Capello
Rafa
Hiddink
Mourinho
Van Gaal
Ancelotti
Lippi
Redknapp
sven
Rijkaard



[/quote]

rednapp better than a league/CL winning manager?

 

[the_khl]

Rafa Rafael
Rafa Rafael
RAFAEL BENITEZ






It's obvious that there are managers on that list that has achieved more than Rafa at this stage but would I swap our current gaffer with anyone on that list.

Big. Fat. No.

 

[grjt]

[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=36114.msg952777#msg952777 date=1254139932]
[quote author=grjt link=topic=36114.msg952767#msg952767 date=1254139518]
Ferguson
Wenger
Capello
Rafa
Hiddink
Mourinho
Van Gaal
Ancelotti
Lippi
Redknapp
sven
Rijkaard



[/quote]

rednapp better than a league/CL winning manager?
[/quote]

I think youve got to look at the longevity of the managerial career, resources available to them, and the number of players that cite them as a pivotal influence in their development.

I dont doubt Rijkaard is a decent manager, but he really had the makings to create a dynasty at Barca and spectacularly failed to manage the situation.

And if were working on the basis of has/ hasnt won the European cup, then the natural extension would be number of times, at which point most of the list (including Wenger) would be knocked off by Ottmar Hitzfeld, would that make sense? No.

 

[gareth_thomas]

i rate Redknapp.

he gets average teams playing decent football and tends to develop a pretty good winning mentality.

His complete lack of loyalty lets him down and i find he likes to work with teams that are certainly underachieving so he has very little to lose.