• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Rank Our Terrible Forwards of the Last Five Years

Status
Not open for further replies.

Dirkus_Circus

Well-Known
Member
David N'gog: 94 appearances, 19 goals
Andy Carroll: 58 appearances, 11 goals
Fabio Borini: 38 appearances, 3 goals
Iago Aspas: 15 appearances, 1 goal
Rickie Lambert: 31 appearances, 3 goals
Mario Balotelli: 26 appearances, 4 goals


It would appear N'gog was massively underrated in his time at LFC
SHwYFIn.gif
 
Most of Rickie Lee's appearances are about 2 minutes long so that's a bit tight on him.

I was saying the other week that Ngog was better for us than Mario has been though.
 
Balotelli is Jovanovic bad. One of the worst strikers to have played for us in the last 15 years. I'd rather have Voronin I think.
 
Voronin, Degen and Jovanovic. Our cunning use of the free transfer system.

Reading this thread is depressing. No wonder we find ourselves without quality upfront. Look at that list..
 
Voronin, Degen and Jovanovic. Our cunning use of the free transfer system.

Reading this thread is depressing. No wonder we find ourselves without quality upfront. Look at that list..
If it makes you feel any better LFC only spent £74,400,000 in transfer fees on the players listed in my first post.
 
I think Balotelli gets more of a raw deal because of the hype and the reputation that surrounds him. Physically and technically he's a decent player, and streets ahead of everyone else on that list. However, his movement, our way of playing and the failure to live up to his name and expectations of him polarise people a little bit. Clearly, he's been a bad buy (not entirely his own fault), but if I needed a player at an important time he would certainly be ahead of most, if not all, of that drivel up there. That's indicative of the level of shite rather than a defence of Mario.
 
I would like Mario a lot more if he was good enough to get picked and put the ball in the net when he was.
 
I think Borini will start scoring again when he returns to a mid-table club in Italy, or goes to a similar level club in the Premier League. He could probably go play in the Dutch league and finish one of the top scorers there (cloggy will know better if that's true).

What often stops him from scoring is the lack of ball control and composure. He seems to know where the spaces are, and strikes the ball well enough, but he doesn't have the skill to bring the ball under control quickly. The technical skill is something he probably can't develop further at this stage, but the composure part can perhaps be fixed with regular minutes which we can't afford him.

While they included penalties (3 or 4?), he did get 12 goals in 41 games in all competitions for Sunderland last season, often playing as a wide forward. That isn't a great record, but it's still a damn sight better than the 3 in 38 for us. In Italy, he scored 10 in 26 for Roma (all competitions), in a season in which they finished 7th.

I hope Rodgers' relationship with Monk helps us in offloading him to Swansea for a decent value. They're really short of strikers there, play a similar style, and Borini should be familiar with Monk from his loan spell several seasons ago. The likes of Ki, Sigurdsson, Shelvey, Montero, Dyer and Routledge are also good/decent players, which means he isn't playing with the dross like at Sunderland. I hope Borini is reading this - get your agent to tap up Swansea!
 
How in the world did Rodgers watch Fabio Borini up close and not realize he wasn't technically good enough to play a part for LFC? Did he really think the step up was so small? Basically there is not a single game we play in where there is enough space afforded to our attackers for Fabio Borini to take a touch and score. Despicable.
 
How in the world did Rodgers watch Fabio Borini up close and not realize he wasn't technically good enough to play a part for LFC? Did he really think the step up was so small? Basically there is not a single game we play in where there is enough space afforded to our attackers for Fabio Borini to take a touch and score. Despicable.
He tried to ship him out and he refused to go. We can't make him leave! He stayed to "fight for his place" despite being told he wasn't part of the plans.
 
He tried to ship him out and he refused to go. We can't make him leave! He stayed to "fight for his place" despite being told he wasn't part of the plans.


I maybe wrong here but I think the poster Lucas meant why did Brendan buy Borini 3 years ago when he had spent decent amount of time coaching him at Chelsea and Swansea.
 
I'm going to defend David Ngog here.

Not to say he was a great player or anything ... but I don't think anyone ever had any big expectations from him surely? Especially as a 1-2M signing ...

At least he scored against United & Arsenal, which I can't recall the other strikers on the list ever doing for us.



 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom