I think this should be based on on field performances over the course of this season.
The manager that i would choose has produced the following impressive stats:
League winner
A record 32 points from 13 games
Played 13 games, won 10, drawn 2, lost 1.
Home: Played 7 won 7
Away: Played 6, won 3, drawn 2, lost 1
Best attack in the league with 28 goals
Best defence in the league with only 7 goals conceded
Has led a average striker to become the leading goal scorer in the league
From 13 games this gaffer has won Manager of the week for a record 6 times in one season.
The manager that i would choose has produced the following impressive stats:
League winner
A record 32 points from 13 games
Played 13 games, won 10, drawn 2, lost 1.
Home: Played 7 won 7
Away: Played 6, won 3, drawn 2, lost 1
Best attack in the league with 28 goals
Best defence in the league with only 7 goals conceded
Has led a average striker to become the leading goal scorer in the league
From 13 games this gaffer has won Manager of the week for a record 6 times in one season.