• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Man City reported to FIFA

Status
Not open for further replies.

Rosco

Worse than Brendan
Member
It's strange that all these investigations are cropping up in the same week ....
Manchester City look set to be investigated by Fifa over their signing of the French teenager Jérémy Hélan after the defender's former club, Rennes, said they had complained to world football's governing body about the transfer.

Hélan, who is 17, joined City in February and Rennes want Fifa to look into the Premier League club's conduct. "We have referred this to Fifa," the technical director, Pierre Dreossi, told the Independent. City are understood to be adamant that they broke no rules in bringing the player, who was then 16, to the club.

Rennes' action comes after Chelsea were given a transfer ban to 2011 by Fifa after being found guilty of illegally inducing Gaël Kakuta to sign from Lens. Chelsea have said they did nothing wrong and that they will appeal.

Hélan, a product of France's Clairefontaine academy, had been a target for Manchester United before he signed for City.

City have made several more high-profile and costly signings since their Middle Eastern owners took over last season but the United defender Rio Ferdinand has warned that the lavish spending is no guarantee of success and said that Manchester is not big enough for two highly successful team.

"I won't like it very much if City start doing well," he said. "This city isn't big enough for two big teams. But they have very loyal supporters who have been crying out for success. Maybe they think their time has come with all the money that has been invested.

"Sometimes money doesn't buy success. It can do, as we saw at Chelsea, but they were starting from finishing fourth, fifth and third in the league. City are starting from a different position."

http://www.guardian.co.uk/football/2009/sep/08/manchester-city-rennes-transfer-fifa-complaint

I'd love to see them get a transfer ban
 
Well, it's opened up a can of worms, hasn't it?

Everyone wants to see if they can get something out of it now.
 
How long till we get caught up in this?

I heard a story yesterday about Man U being accussed of this by Le Harve I think, United's response was to threaten to sue them if they kept accussing them, thats not legal is it?
 
With the amount of 'kids' that we have signed in the last 18 months we will be next on the block for sure. There is no way every single one of those deals are squeaky clean.
 
[quote author=keniget link=topic=35713.msg939961#msg939961 date=1252398713]
Well, it's opened up a can of worms, hasn't it?

Everyone wants to see if they can get something out of it now.
[/quote]

Yeah it looks like the Chelsea ban seems to have made all smaller clubs think this is their turn to get their own back. So far only English clubs have been affected.

I'll bet Platini is happy
 
I would be fabulous if Citeh, scum, Chelski were all banned from transfers for a couple of years. Fucking fabulous.

Wont happen though, they'll all be trading as normal come January or next summer at the very very very latest.
 
[quote author=Mystic link=topic=35713.msg939962#msg939962 date=1252398881]
How long till we get caught up in this?

I heard a story yesterday about Man U being accussed of this by Le Harve I think, United's response was to threaten to sue them if they kept accussing them, thats not legal is it?
[/quote]

How can it NOT be legal ? If you (as an individual or a corporate entity) are being slandered / libelled then you have the right to pursue a legal end to the harrassment. It is a case of put up or shut up. If Le Havre have a case then they had better present it in black & white.
 
[quote author=Rosco link=topic=35713.msg939965#msg939965 date=1252399052]
So far only English clubs have been affected.

I'll bet Platini is happy
[/quote]

So far only English clubs affected with a French club making the accusations? Yup Platini will be very happy
 
[quote author=Asim link=topic=35713.msg940053#msg940053 date=1252408778]
[quote author=Rosco link=topic=35713.msg939965#msg939965 date=1252399052]
So far only English clubs have been affected.

I'll bet Platini is happy
[/quote]

So far only English clubs affected with a French club making the accusations? Yup Platini will be very happy
[/quote]


Chelsea's punishment stank of Platini.
 
[quote author=Frogfish link=topic=35713.msg940049#msg940049 date=1252408125]
[quote author=Mystic link=topic=35713.msg939962#msg939962 date=1252398881]
How long till we get caught up in this?

I heard a story yesterday about Man U being accussed of this by Le Harve I think, United's response was to threaten to sue them if they kept accussing them, thats not legal is it?
[/quote]

How can it NOT be legal ? If you (as an individual or a corporate entity) are being slandered / libelled then you have the right to pursue a legal end to the harrassment. It is a case of put up or shut up. If Le Havre have a case then they had better present it in black & white.
[/quote]

Let me rephrase that, they were saying they were going to take there evidence to uefa and said united did it, to which united said they'd take legal action if they don't drop it. Thats how i read it anyway
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom