I stole this post from RAWK, but it pretty much illustrates my thoughts about the midfield and Henderson.
Brentie http://www.redandwhitekop.com/forum/index.php?topic=308898.msg12136477#msg12136477 said:Im not scared of calling anyone out. We need upgrades on Lucas, Gerrard AND Henderson to challenge for the league. Midfield is our weakest area.
We've spent 68m or so on midfielders since selling Alonso and Masch and we're still in dire need of investment there. Gerrard and Lucas have both lost a yard of pace in recent years due to years and injuries and it has badly affected their mobility. Henderson lacks the technique or goal threat to be a good option for us. All 3 have strengths (Henderson is his running for example) but overall are not good enough anymore or never will be.
Our next signing HAS to be a monster center mid. It's the biggest weak point in our side.
There's been a huge desperation on here and in certain podcasts to elevate Henderson into a key player in our side. Even in his first season when he was generally absolutely awful and anonymous (getting subbed off at half time several times), people were clutching at whatever small straw with Henderson. I remember The Anfield Wrap towards Easter of his first season desperately trying to sell him as a "great signing"
That desperation for me is borne out of a few things: 1) The potential in Henderson which at times, but rarely, points to him developing into a good player and 2) The desire for people to be less embarrassed at Kenny's 2011 Summer dealings by having at least one good signing from that bunch 3) People wanting to be proved right after defending the obscene amount of money we payed for him
That desperation leads to ridiculous efforts to magnify any good things he does. For example, a previous post I quoted said he was MOTM several times this season- he never has been. He's had a couple of games where his running has been very useful (United for example), a couple of others where he did ok and a few where he's been average or downright awful (Sunderland away for example).
He's been compared to a multitude of players, from Xavi, to Lampard to Milner to Gerrard. People see him run a lot and press the ball well and that's enough for him to have had a "great game".
Our standards have gone downhill so fast, and our expectations of him too, that that's all it takes nowadays. I remember him playing an amazing through ball for Downing at City in Jan 2012. When's the last time you saw a Henderson pass cut an entire defense open? I remember his first goal vs Bolton and his performance there after in August 2011. When's the last time you saw him impact our attacking play in the same manner?
Have you seen how long it takes for him to turn on the ball? Where other midfielders take one touch, Henderson takes 3 or 4. His supposed "brilliant" passing skills now revolve on him taking 3 or 4 touches and passing it backwards.
It's happened without a lot of people realising it, but Jordan Henderson has become Rodgers' poor man's Dirk Kuyt. Someone who runs around alot and harries defenders and wins the ball back, but has little creativity and goal threat. Kuyt was always likely to come up with a goal, it's a surprise when Henderson does. Kuyt had a warrior mentality and stepped up when others had poor games. Henderson rarely does.
Is this the player you thought Henderson would develop into? Because, quite frankly, he offers nothing else. No creativity, no goal threat, no great tackling etc... He's a harrier and a runner. And forgive me, but in my opinion Liverpool Football Club should expect a shitload more from a player in the final third who's become a first 11 starter. We shouldn't be in a situation where 10 league games into the season, a player who's mostly played in the final third and started every game has 0 goals and 0 assists.
There are other issues in the side, especially in midfield (as I said previously, we should be looking to upgrade on all 3), but no other player is elevated like Henderson is. It's ridiculous at times. He's no longer a kid. He'll be 24 next Summer, the age Steven Gerrard was when he lifted the European cup for us. People still say Henderson is Gerrard's replacement. It's, quite frankly, absolutely laughable.