• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Downing at LB

Status
Not open for further replies.

rurikbird

Part of the Furniture
Honorary Member
He scored a great goal cutting in on his right foot (reminded me of Philipp Lahm's goal against Costa-Rica) and played a few good passes. Then he committed that awful pass across the penalty box that almost gifted them a goal. What was far more worrying is that during the whole Anzhi attack that resulted from his misplaced pass, Downing just stood in the penalty box, absolutely frozen, watching the ball and playing every Anzhi player onside. Rattled by that episode, he's given the ball away at least a couple more times after that.

I was the first poster here to suggest converting Downing to a full-back. However, at this point, I'm far from sure he can ever be good enough defensively to make it as a defender. And his comments about busting a gut in defense not being "a part of his game" (or something to that effect) show that he is probably not prepared to put his heart and soul into developing those qualities he would need to succeed as a LB. So it was a mixed bag today, on one hand the goal, on the other some shaky defensive play. But on the balance, after today I'm a bit less optimistic that Downing can make it in this team as a full-back - and that's the only role he has any chance of filling in Rodgers' tactical set-up.
 
Did you really mention Downing at LB?

It's really impressive that you and Brendan - you must be on first name terms by now - are thinking similar thoughts. You should start a thread where I can congratulate you further. The fact that you both are completely wrong shouldn't factor into it.
 
We all want to Downing to succeed of course, as we want any Liverpool player to succeed, but it appears as if his brain is broken beyond repair. Playing him at left back was probably an attempt by Rodgers to shake him out of a negative pattern. But bar a very nice and important goal he only offered some serious defensive mistakes. Shame. We should try to get rid in January.
 
Did you really mention Downing at LB?

It's really impressive that you and Brendan - you must be on first name terms by now - are thinking similar thoughts. You should start a thread where I can congratulate you further. The fact that you both are completely wrong shouldn't factor into it.

I'll think about it.
 
Did you really mention Downing at LB?

It's really impressive that you and Brendan - you must be on first name terms by now - are thinking similar thoughts. You should start a thread where I can congratulate you further. The fact that you both are completely wrong shouldn't factor into it.

That's a bit cuntish Squiggs.

Rurick did create a thread championing Downing for LB ages ago. He said it in passing in his post above, he wasn't looking for a pat on the back for suggesting it. He even claimed he was a bit off the mark suggestion Downing for the LB role.
 
One goal doesn't detract from the fact he's shit. He's a terrible lb (as he can't defend what so ever) and he's been diabolical for us in his natural position, the position he played well at other clubs in. It's not worked out, he was a poor buy, we'll flog him as soon as we can I'd have thought. But I can't see us getting more than 5mill for him :s
 
unfortunately for Downing he will never make it here - Brendan's antics in the end were great man management as well as club management - making him feel important and hence indirectly increasing his value!!
 
I think it was embarrassing.

It's like parading the special kid hoping that all the attention will help but all it does is draw attention to the fact that he's special.

At that moment Downing must have been mortified.
 
he's crap. We paid twice what we should have paid for him and will probably get half of that when we sell him, which hopefully, will be in Jan.
 
If Fudgie calls him 'a great technician' one more time I think I'll scream. Maybe he should play in overalls.
 
He won us the game and more or less kept us in the competition. Deserves credit for that. Haven't changed my mind about him though.
 
He's bad, and shouldn't be played at left back especially if Enrique is fit. It was a good goal the other night, bit ironic that it only took him 1 game to score from full back and over a full season to score from his natural position.

*edit* I know Enrique has been shite aswell for the last while but he will be better than Downing defensively and offers as much going forward
 
He's bad, and shouldn't be played at left back especially if Enrique is fit. It was a good goal the other night, bit ironic that it only took him 1 game to score from full back and over a full season to score from his natural position.

*edit* I know Enrique has been shite aswell for the last while but he will be better than Downing defensively and offers as much going forward
agreed
 
He's bad, and shouldn't be played at left back especially if Enrique is fit. It was a good goal the other night, bit ironic that it only took him 1 game to score from full back and over a full season to score from his natural position.

*edit* I know Enrique has been shite aswell for the last while but he will be better than Downing defensively and offers as much going forward

It baffles me to this day that there were some who thought he was anything but "bad" before we utterly wasted 20M on the useless wankhound. Ship him out on a free just to make sure we're rid.... maybe weve signed worse players for similarly ridiculous fees but IMO never has it been so completely obvious prior to a signing. A fucking trocious all day every day... we should end the nightmare and embarrassment of having him asap.
 
It baffles me to this day that there were some who thought he was anything but "bad" before we utterly wasted 20M on the useless wankhound. Ship him out on a free just to make sure we're rid.... maybe weve signed worse players for similarly ridiculous fees but IMO never has it been so completely obvious prior to a signing. A fucking trocious all day every day... we should end the nightmare and embarrassment of having him asap.

I still remember your comments about him when he was linked with us.
 
I praised Downing for his cameo appearance away at Sunderland earlier in the season but really he's been a total disaster since he arrived last summer.

Nice goal the other night and he's got some useful attributes as a winger. He's probably a nice guy as well but he belongs at a Stoke or Fulham.

Hopefully he'll be playing for a team like that come January. It'd benefit all parties.
 
I praised Downing for his cameo appearance away at Sunderland earlier in the season but really he's been a total disaster since he arrived last summer.

Nice goal the other night and he's got some useful attributes as a winger. He's probably a nice guy as well but he belongs at a Stoke or Fulham.

Hopefully he'll be playing for a team like that come January. It'd benefit all parties.
Would you like to add anything further to that Gary😎
 
We all want to Downing to succeed of course, as we want any Liverpool player to succeed, but it appears as if his brain is broken beyond repair. Playing him at left back was probably an attempt by Rodgers to shake him out of a negative pattern. But bar a very nice and important goal he only offered some serious defensive mistakes. Shame. We should try to get rid in January.

Based on my experience on this site the bit in your post that says: - "We all want to Downing to succeed of course, as we want any Liverpool player to succeed..."

is not true I am afraid - most want him dead or removed from the club.
 
I definitely thought he would be better than he has been. But, I didn't know his mentality was so poor. He has the physical attributes and skill to have been much better.
 
I definitely thought he would be better than he has been. But, I didn't know his mentality was so poor. He has the physical attributes and skill to have been much better.

If only he could be hypnotized into thinking he was always playing against Liverpool. He seemed decent when playing against Liverpool.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom