• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Carra: 'I hope Fellaini never plays again in the PL'

Status
Not open for further replies.

gkmacca

6CM Addict
Member
It's taken a mystifyingly long time - a scandalously long time, in fact - for this twat to get his comeuppance, but, hopefully, at last it's finally happening:

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/fo...plays-Premier-League-again.html#ixzz47zBxdfgM

33B6568000000578-3577673-The_Belgian_midfielder_made_contact_with_the_German_s_neck_with_-a-48_1462563412465.jpg


How did they get the same bans? One man deliberately swings an elbow, knowing full well the damage that can be caused. The other grabs a clump of hair. Both, somehow, end up with three-match suspensions.

The more I look at the punishments that Marouane Fellaini and Robert Huth received, the less I can understand the Football Association's decision. Huth, a giant in Leicester's fairytale campaign, misses his side's big celebration for an incident you associate with a school playground.

Yet Fellaini could end up playing in the FA Cup final. Can pulling someone's hair cause the same damage as a flailing elbow? No. Not in a million years.

It can't be right that he will be available for Manchester United's big day against Crystal Palace on May 21. My personal hope is that we would never see him playing in the Premier League again.

Three games is not a sentence that will prove a deterrent to Fellaini. He is a repeat offender and it has gone beyond the point now where people can attempt to defend him by saying he is a tall lad who is using his arms for leverage.


Look at the incident with Huth again: Fellaini takes a glance around and sees where Huth is before swinging. Yes, he may have been provoked but the Belgium international knew what he was doing. Had he connected firmly, the Leicester defender could have been left with a broken cheek or jaw.

Gary Mabbutt, the former Tottenham captain, would testify to that. Back in November 1993, he was left with a fractured skull and needed a plate inserted into his face to hold his eye socket together after John Fashanu smashed his elbow into him during a game against Wimbledon.

Yet should we be surprised it was Fellaini again? No. He argued back in March that he 'doesn't want to elbow someone and only defend myself' but that simply doesn't hold any credibility because he has been involved in too many incidents.

What happened when United faced Liverpool in the Europa League? He escaped retrospective punishment for elbowing Emre Can at Anfield in the first leg on March 10 but then seven days later at Old Trafford, he did exactly the same thing only this time Dejan Lovren was on the receiving end.

When he first arrived in the Premier League, as Everton's record £15million signing in 2008, he was booked five times in his first two months. The assumption, initially, was to put it down to exuberance, awkwardness and immaturity. But here we are, eight years on, and he hasn't changed.

The figures are damning. He has been booked 61 times in all competitions since coming to England and picked up a further three red cards. He has served 18 matches in bans, including three for a headbutt on Stoke's Ryan Shawcross when he was at Everton that enraged David Moyes.

I hated playing against Fellaini. You knew from the word go you had to keep your wits because of his aggression. In one Merseyside derby, TV cameras showed me telling the referee to 'watch Fellaini's elbows' — he always featured in our team talks because he was so awkward.

He is a menace in the worst possible sense. I don't use that term lightly but he is not a Manchester United player in any shape or form.

I was never convinced he would fit in at Old Trafford when he left Goodison Park and have never been given reason to change my mind. Yes, he's a good player with some qualities but he is absolutely not United standard.

Over the years, there have always been players who have crossed the line. Luis Suarez had a habit of doing it; Eric Cantona did and so too did Patrick Vieira. They were all involved in moments that were unacceptable.

Every player will have a few moments that disappoint them when they look back. The biggest one of mine was a challenge on Nani at Anfield during a game against Manchester United in March 2011.
Still to this day I do not know how I never got sent off. I apologised immediately and did so again afterwards but it couldn't make up for what I had done.

I was on the end of a similar tackle from Lucas Neill that broke my leg and the older you become the stronger your feelings are not to see a fellow professional get hurt.

Kevin Muscat, the former Wolves player, had a reputation for doing just that and Fellaini is in danger of slipping into the same realms. For him to still be guilty of the same kind of incidents shows how big the issue has become and it was significant to see Louis van Gaal raise the issue of him having to control his temper.

He isn't learning and he is now getting the kind of reputation where players will be worried on a weekly basis about getting hurt when they come up against him.

For the next three games, that threat will be removed. But afterwards? Who knows? I can't believe that he still has a chance to end his season at Wembley when the reality is he should be banned for longer.

Personally I hope we don’t see his elbows in England again.
 
This point is broader, and something I've moaned about repeatedly over the years, it seems for some reason we as a nation have no problem with good old fashion thuggery, two footed challenges, stamps, studs up, elbows and head butts, they're fine, at most you'll get a three match ban and be called a thug. However if you were to dive, or spit, or heaven forbid bite someone you'd be hounded by the press and the nation, and for the latter two bit hit with an equal or worse ban. Now that's fine, they deserve that treatment, but for the former group the danger to the pro is much more real and these incidents need to be treated with much more severity reflecting that.

I have to give the FA some due as they totally surprised me with the 6 match ban for Dembele, but it was 100% the right one, but still as evidenced with the non action against Funi Mori and this latest incident, a lot more needs to be done.
 
It is up to the referees and the FA to protect the players from players like him. It is not not having a winter break that is the problem in English football. It is as already been pointed out in the thread by Mystic the refeeres and the FA that is the problem. The referees allow to much. They must start to show many more yellow and red cards or the clubs will continue to have big injury problems.

Elbowing someone in the head should be at least a 10 game ban. The second time a 20 game ban and a third time a 40 game ban and so on. As it is now you get a longer ban if you spit on someone than if you break someones leg.

Clattenburg showed a lot of yellow cards in the Tottenham Chelsea game but he should have shown at least five or six red cards. You can see career ending tackles yellow carded.

The players now play so many games that a three game ban is a drop in the ocean.
 
It's a start but would mean more were it not coming from an ex-Liverpool player.
Yet Carra coming out and saying this, considering his position with Sky, raises the profile and focuses attention on the issue (and Fellaini) all the more. Well done Carra.
 
They were discussing this yesterday on TalkSh!te and that dipsh!t Cundy was laying into Carra for it, saying he'd gone way OTT, despite the fact that his co-host and a journo in the studio were both telling him, politely, not to be such an idiot. The little Cockney tw@t is really bitter, isn't he?
 
Jason Cundy. One letter away from his surname describing him perfectly.

He's even more unsubtle than Durham when it comes to hyperbolic wind ups.
 
They were discussing this yesterday on TalkSh!te and that dipsh!t Cundy was laying into Carra for it, saying he'd gone way OTT, despite the fact that his co-host and a journo in the studio were both telling him, politely, not to be such an idiot. The little Cockney tw@t is really bitter, isn't he?

Quite. What's really disgraceful is that Fellaini should have been getting yellow and red cards for this from his first season onwards, but it was as if refs looked at him and thought, 'Gawd, we'll be sending him off every game we ref if we react to that stuff,' so they allowed it to become invisible. He would just blatantly aim his elbows at any player who got close and then exploit the ridiculous amount of space he'd get as a consequence. It's been absolutely scandalous.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom