9's or 7's?
- Thread starter reuque
- Start date
- Latest activity Latest activity:
- Status
[quote author=reuque link=topic=34924.msg912399#msg912399 date=1248614537]
Which number has produced the better line of star players for us?
7: Dalglish, Barnes
9: Rush, Fowler, Torres
Feel free to add.
[/quote]
barnes was number 10
Which number has produced the better line of star players for us?
7: Dalglish, Barnes
9: Rush, Fowler, Torres
Feel free to add.
[/quote]
barnes was number 10
10. barnes, owen, keegan(?)
This thread is going well.
[quote author=Red Mullet link=topic=34924.msg912408#msg912408 date=1248614950]
This thread is going well.
[/quote]
ha ha, it's been so long since kev was at the club ;D
This thread is going well.
[/quote]
ha ha, it's been so long since kev was at the club ;D
I love this thread ;D
Here's my recollection:
7: Keegan, Dalglish, Beardsley, McManaman (as well as Clough, Smicer, Kewell, Keane etc.)
8. St. John, Case, Lee, Aldridge, Gerrard (as well as Collymore)
9: Heighway, Johnson, Rush, Fowler, Torres (as well as Houghton, Cisse (?)
10: Toshack, McDermott, Molby (?), Barnes, Owen (as well as Voronin)
#7 for me.
Here's my recollection:
7: Keegan, Dalglish, Beardsley, McManaman (as well as Clough, Smicer, Kewell, Keane etc.)
8. St. John, Case, Lee, Aldridge, Gerrard (as well as Collymore)
9: Heighway, Johnson, Rush, Fowler, Torres (as well as Houghton, Cisse (?)
10: Toshack, McDermott, Molby (?), Barnes, Owen (as well as Voronin)
#7 for me.
[quote author=jimmy link=topic=34924.msg912455#msg912455 date=1248622737]
I love this thread ;D
Here's my recollection:
7: Keegan, Dalglish, Beardsley, McManaman (as well as Clough, Smicer, Kewell, Keane etc.)
8. St. John, Case, Lee, Aldridge, Gerrard (as well as Collymore)
9: Heighway, Johnson, Rush, Fowler, Torres (as well as Houghton, Cisse (?)
10: Toshack, McDermott, Molby (?), Barnes, Owen (as well as Voronin)
#7 for me.
[/quote]
i'm pretty sure st john wore 9, and hunt wore 8.
i'm shocked at some of the ignorance here, not st john so much, but getting keegan & barnes wrong is just, well, wrong.
I love this thread ;D
Here's my recollection:
7: Keegan, Dalglish, Beardsley, McManaman (as well as Clough, Smicer, Kewell, Keane etc.)
8. St. John, Case, Lee, Aldridge, Gerrard (as well as Collymore)
9: Heighway, Johnson, Rush, Fowler, Torres (as well as Houghton, Cisse (?)
10: Toshack, McDermott, Molby (?), Barnes, Owen (as well as Voronin)
#7 for me.
[/quote]
i'm pretty sure st john wore 9, and hunt wore 8.
i'm shocked at some of the ignorance here, not st john so much, but getting keegan & barnes wrong is just, well, wrong.
[quote author=peterhague link=topic=34924.msg912466#msg912466 date=1248624712]
[quote author=jimmy link=topic=34924.msg912455#msg912455 date=1248622737]
I love this thread ;D
Here's my recollection:
7: Keegan, Dalglish, Beardsley, McManaman (as well as Clough, Smicer, Kewell, Keane etc.)
8. St. John, Case, Lee, Aldridge, Gerrard (as well as Collymore)
9: Heighway, Johnson, Rush, Fowler, Torres (as well as Houghton, Cisse (?)
10: Toshack, McDermott, Molby (?), Barnes, Owen (as well as Voronin)
#7 for me.
[/quote]
i'm pretty sure st john wore 9, and hunt wore 8.
i'm shocked at some of the ignorance here, not st john so much, but getting keegan & barnes wrong is just, well, wrong.
[/quote]
I was half-asleep when I started this thread.
[quote author=jimmy link=topic=34924.msg912455#msg912455 date=1248622737]
I love this thread ;D
Here's my recollection:
7: Keegan, Dalglish, Beardsley, McManaman (as well as Clough, Smicer, Kewell, Keane etc.)
8. St. John, Case, Lee, Aldridge, Gerrard (as well as Collymore)
9: Heighway, Johnson, Rush, Fowler, Torres (as well as Houghton, Cisse (?)
10: Toshack, McDermott, Molby (?), Barnes, Owen (as well as Voronin)
#7 for me.
[/quote]
i'm pretty sure st john wore 9, and hunt wore 8.
i'm shocked at some of the ignorance here, not st john so much, but getting keegan & barnes wrong is just, well, wrong.
[/quote]
I was half-asleep when I started this thread.
don't pay much attention to the number on the back only the liverbird on the front (which is far too small).
for me it will always be 10 because of the great john barnes. the tradition of great number 10's is currently being magnificently upheld with the sublime voronin.
for me it will always be 10 because of the great john barnes. the tradition of great number 10's is currently being magnificently upheld with the sublime voronin.
1. Clem, Grobs, the dude and pepe.
Torres hasn't done nearly enough yet, but assuming he goes on to achieve what we expect, and in addition to Rush and Fowler, I think No.9 edges it.
I rate all three of them as higher than the next best No.7 after KD. I never saw KK I'm afraid and Bearsdley, whilst great, isn't a true LFc great.
I rate all three of them as higher than the next best No.7 after KD. I never saw KK I'm afraid and Bearsdley, whilst great, isn't a true LFc great.
[quote author=Red Mullet link=topic=34924.msg912520#msg912520 date=1248634379]
1. Clem, Grobs, the dude and pepe.
[/quote]
Erm... if I respond am I going to be whooshed?
1. Clem, Grobs, the dude and pepe.
[/quote]
Erm... if I respond am I going to be whooshed?
[quote author=Flanders link=topic=34924.msg912543#msg912543 date=1248639936]
[quote author=Red Mullet link=topic=34924.msg912408#msg912408 date=1248614950]
This thread is going well.
[/quote]
LOL! I hope it isn't indicative of the knowledge on this board! I'll read on.... 🙂
[/quote]
You should meet Brendan
[quote author=Red Mullet link=topic=34924.msg912408#msg912408 date=1248614950]
This thread is going well.
[/quote]
LOL! I hope it isn't indicative of the knowledge on this board! I'll read on.... 🙂
[/quote]
You should meet Brendan
[quote author=Flanders link=topic=34924.msg912545#msg912545 date=1248640198]
Torres hasn't done nearly enough yet, but assuming he goes on to achieve what we expect, and in addition to Rush and Fowler, I think No.9 edges it.
I rate all three of them as higher than the next best No.7 after KD. I never saw KK I'm afraid and Bearsdley, whilst great, isn't a true LFc great.
[/quote]
Dalglish > Rush - 2 legends but even Rushy has to take second-billing to King Kenny.
Keegan > Fowler - A lot of younger posters under estimate Keegan's role in our success in the 70's and IMO he is second in the all-time list of LFC greats behind Kenny.
Beardsley > Torres - Obviously this will change if Torres continues his LFC career in similar fashion to the way he has started.
As things stand the score is 7's 3-0 9's.
Torres hasn't done nearly enough yet, but assuming he goes on to achieve what we expect, and in addition to Rush and Fowler, I think No.9 edges it.
I rate all three of them as higher than the next best No.7 after KD. I never saw KK I'm afraid and Bearsdley, whilst great, isn't a true LFc great.
[/quote]
Dalglish > Rush - 2 legends but even Rushy has to take second-billing to King Kenny.
Keegan > Fowler - A lot of younger posters under estimate Keegan's role in our success in the 70's and IMO he is second in the all-time list of LFC greats behind Kenny.
Beardsley > Torres - Obviously this will change if Torres continues his LFC career in similar fashion to the way he has started.
As things stand the score is 7's 3-0 9's.
[quote author=Pesam link=topic=34924.msg912649#msg912649 date=1248684377]
[quote author=Flanders link=topic=34924.msg912545#msg912545 date=1248640198]
Torres hasn't done nearly enough yet, but assuming he goes on to achieve what we expect, and in addition to Rush and Fowler, I think No.9 edges it.
I rate all three of them as higher than the next best No.7 after KD. I never saw KK I'm afraid and Bearsdley, whilst great, isn't a true LFc great.
[/quote]
Dalglish > Rush - 2 legends but even Rushy has to take second-billing to King Kenny.
Keegan > Fowler - A lot of younger posters under estimate Keegan's role in our success in the 70's and IMO he is second in the all-time list of LFC greats behind Kenny.
Beardsley > Torres - Obviously this will change if Torres continues his LFC career in similar fashion to the way he has started.
As things stand the score is 7's 3-0 9's.
[/quote]
Can't diagree with that but..... petty as it may seem.
Rush, Fowler and hopefully Torres will be the same, are recognised as Liverpool Legends.
KK and Beardsley will always be Newcastle legends in the eyes of the greater football world.
[quote author=Flanders link=topic=34924.msg912545#msg912545 date=1248640198]
Torres hasn't done nearly enough yet, but assuming he goes on to achieve what we expect, and in addition to Rush and Fowler, I think No.9 edges it.
I rate all three of them as higher than the next best No.7 after KD. I never saw KK I'm afraid and Bearsdley, whilst great, isn't a true LFc great.
[/quote]
Dalglish > Rush - 2 legends but even Rushy has to take second-billing to King Kenny.
Keegan > Fowler - A lot of younger posters under estimate Keegan's role in our success in the 70's and IMO he is second in the all-time list of LFC greats behind Kenny.
Beardsley > Torres - Obviously this will change if Torres continues his LFC career in similar fashion to the way he has started.
As things stand the score is 7's 3-0 9's.
[/quote]
Can't diagree with that but..... petty as it may seem.
Rush, Fowler and hopefully Torres will be the same, are recognised as Liverpool Legends.
KK and Beardsley will always be Newcastle legends in the eyes of the greater football world.
[quote author=Flanders link=topic=34924.msg912701#msg912701 date=1248689997]
[quote author=Pesam link=topic=34924.msg912649#msg912649 date=1248684377]
[quote author=Flanders link=topic=34924.msg912545#msg912545 date=1248640198]
Torres hasn't done nearly enough yet, but assuming he goes on to achieve what we expect, and in addition to Rush and Fowler, I think No.9 edges it.
I rate all three of them as higher than the next best No.7 after KD. I never saw KK I'm afraid and Bearsdley, whilst great, isn't a true LFc great.
[/quote]
Dalglish > Rush - 2 legends but even Rushy has to take second-billing to King Kenny.
Keegan > Fowler - A lot of younger posters under estimate Keegan's role in our success in the 70's and IMO he is second in the all-time list of LFC greats behind Kenny.
Beardsley > Torres - Obviously this will change if Torres continues his LFC career in similar fashion to the way he has started.
As things stand the score is 7's 3-0 9's.
[/quote]
Can't diagree with that but..... petty as it may seem.
Rush, Fowler and hopefully Torres will be the same, are recognised as Liverpool Legends.
KK and Beardsley will always be Newcastle legends in the eyes of the greater football world.
[/quote]
are you the flanders from koptalk?
[quote author=Pesam link=topic=34924.msg912649#msg912649 date=1248684377]
[quote author=Flanders link=topic=34924.msg912545#msg912545 date=1248640198]
Torres hasn't done nearly enough yet, but assuming he goes on to achieve what we expect, and in addition to Rush and Fowler, I think No.9 edges it.
I rate all three of them as higher than the next best No.7 after KD. I never saw KK I'm afraid and Bearsdley, whilst great, isn't a true LFc great.
[/quote]
Dalglish > Rush - 2 legends but even Rushy has to take second-billing to King Kenny.
Keegan > Fowler - A lot of younger posters under estimate Keegan's role in our success in the 70's and IMO he is second in the all-time list of LFC greats behind Kenny.
Beardsley > Torres - Obviously this will change if Torres continues his LFC career in similar fashion to the way he has started.
As things stand the score is 7's 3-0 9's.
[/quote]
Can't diagree with that but..... petty as it may seem.
Rush, Fowler and hopefully Torres will be the same, are recognised as Liverpool Legends.
KK and Beardsley will always be Newcastle legends in the eyes of the greater football world.
[/quote]
are you the flanders from koptalk?
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=34924.msg912703#msg912703 date=1248690173]
[quote author=Flanders link=topic=34924.msg912701#msg912701 date=1248689997]
[quote author=Pesam link=topic=34924.msg912649#msg912649 date=1248684377]
[quote author=Flanders link=topic=34924.msg912545#msg912545 date=1248640198]
Torres hasn't done nearly enough yet, but assuming he goes on to achieve what we expect, and in addition to Rush and Fowler, I think No.9 edges it.
I rate all three of them as higher than the next best No.7 after KD. I never saw KK I'm afraid and Bearsdley, whilst great, isn't a true LFc great.
[/quote]
Dalglish > Rush - 2 legends but even Rushy has to take second-billing to King Kenny.
Keegan > Fowler - A lot of younger posters under estimate Keegan's role in our success in the 70's and IMO he is second in the all-time list of LFC greats behind Kenny.
Beardsley > Torres - Obviously this will change if Torres continues his LFC career in similar fashion to the way he has started.
As things stand the score is 7's 3-0 9's.
[/quote]
Can't diagree with that but..... petty as it may seem.
Rush, Fowler and hopefully Torres will be the same, are recognised as Liverpool Legends.
KK and Beardsley will always be Newcastle legends in the eyes of the greater football world.
[/quote]
are you the flanders from koptalk?
[/quote]
Yes, although I haven't been on that site for years.
[quote author=Flanders link=topic=34924.msg912701#msg912701 date=1248689997]
[quote author=Pesam link=topic=34924.msg912649#msg912649 date=1248684377]
[quote author=Flanders link=topic=34924.msg912545#msg912545 date=1248640198]
Torres hasn't done nearly enough yet, but assuming he goes on to achieve what we expect, and in addition to Rush and Fowler, I think No.9 edges it.
I rate all three of them as higher than the next best No.7 after KD. I never saw KK I'm afraid and Bearsdley, whilst great, isn't a true LFc great.
[/quote]
Dalglish > Rush - 2 legends but even Rushy has to take second-billing to King Kenny.
Keegan > Fowler - A lot of younger posters under estimate Keegan's role in our success in the 70's and IMO he is second in the all-time list of LFC greats behind Kenny.
Beardsley > Torres - Obviously this will change if Torres continues his LFC career in similar fashion to the way he has started.
As things stand the score is 7's 3-0 9's.
[/quote]
Can't diagree with that but..... petty as it may seem.
Rush, Fowler and hopefully Torres will be the same, are recognised as Liverpool Legends.
KK and Beardsley will always be Newcastle legends in the eyes of the greater football world.
[/quote]
are you the flanders from koptalk?
[/quote]
Yes, although I haven't been on that site for years.
[quote author=SaintGeorge67 link=topic=34924.msg912561#msg912561 date=1248642451]
[quote author=Red Mullet link=topic=34924.msg912520#msg912520 date=1248634379]
1. Clem, Grobs, the dude and pepe.
[/quote]
Erm... if I respond am I going to be whooshed?
[/quote]
Wouldn't dream of whooshing.
[quote author=Red Mullet link=topic=34924.msg912520#msg912520 date=1248634379]
1. Clem, Grobs, the dude and pepe.
[/quote]
Erm... if I respond am I going to be whooshed?
[/quote]
Wouldn't dream of whooshing.
[quote author=Flanders link=topic=34924.msg912710#msg912710 date=1248690960]
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=34924.msg912703#msg912703 date=1248690173]
[quote author=Flanders link=topic=34924.msg912701#msg912701 date=1248689997]
[quote author=Pesam link=topic=34924.msg912649#msg912649 date=1248684377]
[quote author=Flanders link=topic=34924.msg912545#msg912545 date=1248640198]
Torres hasn't done nearly enough yet, but assuming he goes on to achieve what we expect, and in addition to Rush and Fowler, I think No.9 edges it.
I rate all three of them as higher than the next best No.7 after KD. I never saw KK I'm afraid and Bearsdley, whilst great, isn't a true LFc great.
[/quote]
Dalglish > Rush - 2 legends but even Rushy has to take second-billing to King Kenny.
Keegan > Fowler - A lot of younger posters under estimate Keegan's role in our success in the 70's and IMO he is second in the all-time list of LFC greats behind Kenny.
Beardsley > Torres - Obviously this will change if Torres continues his LFC career in similar fashion to the way he has started.
As things stand the score is 7's 3-0 9's.
[/quote]
Can't diagree with that but..... petty as it may seem.
Rush, Fowler and hopefully Torres will be the same, are recognised as Liverpool Legends.
KK and Beardsley will always be Newcastle legends in the eyes of the greater football world.
[/quote]
are you the flanders from koptalk?
[/quote]
Yes, although I haven't been on that site for years.
[/quote]
how are you? long time no speak 🙂
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=34924.msg912703#msg912703 date=1248690173]
[quote author=Flanders link=topic=34924.msg912701#msg912701 date=1248689997]
[quote author=Pesam link=topic=34924.msg912649#msg912649 date=1248684377]
[quote author=Flanders link=topic=34924.msg912545#msg912545 date=1248640198]
Torres hasn't done nearly enough yet, but assuming he goes on to achieve what we expect, and in addition to Rush and Fowler, I think No.9 edges it.
I rate all three of them as higher than the next best No.7 after KD. I never saw KK I'm afraid and Bearsdley, whilst great, isn't a true LFc great.
[/quote]
Dalglish > Rush - 2 legends but even Rushy has to take second-billing to King Kenny.
Keegan > Fowler - A lot of younger posters under estimate Keegan's role in our success in the 70's and IMO he is second in the all-time list of LFC greats behind Kenny.
Beardsley > Torres - Obviously this will change if Torres continues his LFC career in similar fashion to the way he has started.
As things stand the score is 7's 3-0 9's.
[/quote]
Can't diagree with that but..... petty as it may seem.
Rush, Fowler and hopefully Torres will be the same, are recognised as Liverpool Legends.
KK and Beardsley will always be Newcastle legends in the eyes of the greater football world.
[/quote]
are you the flanders from koptalk?
[/quote]
Yes, although I haven't been on that site for years.
[/quote]
how are you? long time no speak 🙂
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=34924.msg912742#msg912742 date=1248694281]
[quote author=Flanders link=topic=34924.msg912710#msg912710 date=1248690960]
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=34924.msg912703#msg912703 date=1248690173]
are you the flanders from koptalk?
[/quote]
Yes, although I haven't been on that site for years.
[/quote]
how are you? long time no speak 🙂
[/quote]
Pretty good thanks. This seems like a pretty decent forum, have you been on here for a while? I've seen a few other old names I recognise.
[quote author=Flanders link=topic=34924.msg912710#msg912710 date=1248690960]
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=34924.msg912703#msg912703 date=1248690173]
are you the flanders from koptalk?
[/quote]
Yes, although I haven't been on that site for years.
[/quote]
how are you? long time no speak 🙂
[/quote]
Pretty good thanks. This seems like a pretty decent forum, have you been on here for a while? I've seen a few other old names I recognise.
[quote author=Whaddapie link=topic=34924.msg912873#msg912873 date=1248705119]
It's gotta be no. 5, chaps...
Ray Kennedy, Ronnie Whelan, Craig Johnston (at times), Daniel Agger, Steve McMahon.
No question.
[/quote]
Hmmm. Decent enough shout. Didn't Steve McMahon wear number 11?
Mark Wright wore number 5 too I think. I used to quite like Mark Wright.
The only slightly woeful number 5 I can think of is Milan Baros and even he had his moments
It's gotta be no. 5, chaps...
Ray Kennedy, Ronnie Whelan, Craig Johnston (at times), Daniel Agger, Steve McMahon.
No question.
[/quote]
Hmmm. Decent enough shout. Didn't Steve McMahon wear number 11?
Mark Wright wore number 5 too I think. I used to quite like Mark Wright.
The only slightly woeful number 5 I can think of is Milan Baros and even he had his moments
- Status